I told Mycah I’d be snagging this, so I finally am. I tried not to duplicate the guys she picked, but I simply had to include a few of them because they are so awesome. On to the list (in alphabetical order)…
Alan Cumming
Is he perfectly perfect? No. Does it matter? No. He’s Scottish, he can sing and he can act and he looks fabulous doing every single bit of it. He also just seems like a genuinely cool guy. If you have any doubt of his hotness, you should watch the little sex scene between Alan and Daniela Sea in season 3 of The L Word because dayum!
Bryan Greenberg
I fell for this talented young man back in his days on One Tree Hill. There is some big time talent right here, he just needs to be given a few larger scale projects for the rest of the world to see it.
Butch Walker
Butch is S-E-X. Simple as that. I’ve been lucky enough to meet him twice and I couldn’t have asked for a nicer guy. If you haven’t seen or heard this man’s solo acoustic set then you are missing out on some kick ass, emotionally charged music. Stateline is one of my favorite songs to see performed live (clicky already and watch the vid would ya).
Enrique Murciano
If you’ve ever seen Without a Trace then you know why I started loving this guy. If you’ve ever seen him interviewed, especially by Ellen, then you know why I still love this guy and think he’s super sexy and just plain fun. Not only can he act his ass off and make me cry in the process, he’s also hilarious, plays the ukulele and is supposedly a fab cook.
Eric Mabius
Oh, Eric! I fell for this man 10 years ago while watching Black Circle Boys and have continued to follow his career ever since. He’s a wonderfully talented actor and beautiful to boot. If you are only just discovering him because of Ugly Betty, I highly recommend you go back and watch some of his earlier work.
James McAvoy
James is an absolutely amazing actor. If you aren’t familiar with his work yet, go forth and rent some of his films because you will not be disappointed. Did I mention that he’s Scottish? 
James Duval & Sarah Lassez
OK, so this is a two for one entry but they are both just so pretty that I couldn’t help it. I adore them both, but since this is my sexy ‘guy’ list, I’ll be good and talk about Jimmy for a moment. This man really can act. I know you’ve all probably seen him play the nubile young thing in Gregg Araki’s early films or seen him play a doofus in countless things, but that’s not what he’s all about. Watch Mad Cowgirl, The Doe Boy and Donnie Darko to see what he’s truly made of.
Joseph Gordon-Levitt
Words cannot do justice to how talented Joey is. Watch his films and learn for yourself. You will not be sorry.
Justin Theroux
“Yum” is the first word that comes to mind when I think of Justin, but he’s not just another pretty face and smokin’ body. Oh no. This man can give some of my other faves a run for their money in the acting department. And I hear he’s super cool.
Ryan Gosling
Ryan just has this intensity about him that I love to see in my favorite actors. He’s also super tall and incredibly handsome and all 3 make for a winning combo in my book.
Scott Porter
He’s pretty. He’s talented as hell and can act with only his eyes (this is actually a rarity in Hollywood). He can sing. He can dance. He’s a fanboy at heart. He’s a bona fide geek who loves comic books and actually goes to the comic book shop each week to pick up the new arrivals. He’s also an online gamer and blogs in gamer forums and stuff and I may be in the minority, but I find that insanely sexy.
Honorable Mentions Adrian Pasdar, Bruce Campbell, Clive Owen, Dash Mihok, Drake Bell, Jeffrey Donovan, Jonathan Togo, Milo Ventimiglia, Nathan Baesel, Peter Sarsgaard, Shia LaBeouf, Simon Pegg, Tahmoh Penikett, Zachary Quinto
I like your list a lot! I just watched both The Lookout and Mysterious Skin this week and I’m officially IN LOVE with Joe – obsessed love. Not only is he so sexy, my gosh he’s so amazingly talented – powerful & subtle at the same time. He genuinely comes across as a nice guy too! Bonus! (He jumped to my fourth favorite actor officially – damn I’m smitten lol)
I remember watching Black Circle Boys – if I recall I was watching it for Scott Bairstow haha!
I also must admit, I have a huge crush on Shia after seeing Disturbia. It doesn’t hurt he’s so funny
Glad you enjoyed it. I can’t wait to see The Lookout! Yay another obsessee! I’m not really sure if that’s even a word, but whatever. He’s awesomely awesome and it’s always good to hear people appreciate his work and talent because he’s got that in spades.
You know, I actually rented it because of Scott Bairstow too. I had the hugest crush on him until I found out about all that skeezy stuff with him and that 12 year old girl. Gross x infinity! I have zero respect for him anymore.
Hee! Shia is adorable and I have to say that I did think he kind of went from cute to hot once I saw Transformers and Disturbia. Not to be a total perv, but he looks like a really, really good kisser. You can’t not notice it in Disturbia and it’s kinda hot.
I just found out that Dash Mihok has been cast in Cavemen, the new sitcom based on the Geico commercials. Naturally, I thought, “Ooh, does Stef know this?”
He was going to be in it, but he’s already been replaced by Sam Huntington. They have written his character out and have re-shot all of his scenes from the pilot to incorporate in the new character that Sam will play. I still don’t know the exact reason for the re-tooling of the show and I can’t say that I’m disappointed that he won’t be on it because it seems like a really bad idea for a show to begin with. Sure, we all get a kick out of the commercials, but a whole 30 minutes about them? Not the greatest idea ever in my opinion.
Yes! I was watching Disturbia and I was like gosh he seems like a great kisser. BIG pet peeve in movies is when they don’t kiss with tongue, I know I’m a perv and all but I hate when two people “love” each other and have this big love/sex scene and they just do this peck thing, it bugs the crap out of me, and it doesn’t even have to be a gross tongue kiss like in some movies it’s just TOO much, but in Disturbia it was full on tongue action but in a good way LMAO.
Ditto about Scott!
I’m so glad I wasn’t the only one thinking that. Now I don’t feel like quite like such a big perv. I hate that pecking thing too and I’ve seen some of the hottest people on film do it. Ugh!
Finally! Someone else who knows about the dirty Scott stuff. So gross! Did you ever read that one article that had a transcript of their telephone conversation? It gave me the willies and I think there was even some audio floating around at one point too.
No I didn’t read or hear that, just heard about it a few years after it happened. I was just recently reading on IMDB when this came up and all these people are defending him – WTF! I mean I can be understanding if it was like a 15 year old, because most 15 year olds (hell 14) develop super early and you wouldn’t know. But even when I was 12, and I developed at like 9 lol, I still looked very young and you knew it wasn’t ‘of age’ but I may not have looked 9, thats what I picture with a 12 year old and there is just NO excuse to me, Regardless of it was REALLY a rape or her being consenting you know, she’s 12 fucking years old – thats NOT consenting to me because it’s WAY to young and a child. It’s just gross & sick! And I believe he was married – I think maybe not
People were actually defending him? Sick! Yet another reason why I don’t read the IMDB boards much because they just piss me off. Ugh! I totally agree with you and I too developed early, but you could still tell I was young as well. And he was married at the time and the girl was a relative of his wife’s, so not only was she a minor, she was also family. Gross! Gross! Gross!!!
Hey Stef!!! I love the new layout – did you know that Jessica Biel is my “body ideal” – my goal for my weight loss and shaping of my old bod? Whoo! Don’t be such a stranger!!! J